GuyWhoLikesSport

The AFL'S Rut Index

The AFL'S Rut Index

• GuyWhoLikesSport

As I’m writing this in Melbourne, it’s bloody cold.   Over the last five weeks, the AFL is scoring three fewer points per team per game than across the whole season.   Even with a couple of bangers last weekend, we’re officially in the dog days of the season, and a few of the teams that we expected to be good or goodish heading into the season are in a rut.   Everyone reading this, and the fella writing it, have all been in ruts before – whether they be personal or in relationships.   Sometimes, the rut is terminal to the relationship. Other times, your partner just needs to dress up like a cop and you need…

Read More
The Gold Coast Tribute Band

The Gold Coast Tribute Band

• GuyWhoLikesSport

Brisbane and Gold Coast played in the “I’m not desperate yet but I’m getting there cup” on Saturday evening, also known as the Q Clash.   In the end, Brisbane got back to what they have done well and ultimately beat the Suns pretty easily. The Lions spent nearly 58% of the game in their front half, took about 100 marks, handily won clearance and contested ball, and held Gold Coast to 20 front half points.   It was the Brisbane formula from the last few years applied again to an opponent that simply could not go with them.   But why couldn’t Gold Coast go with them?   They…

Read More
The Tortured History of the AFL's Favourite Sons

The Tortured History of the AFL's Favourite Sons

• GuyWhoLikesSport

I don’t know if you saw the news, but Essendon sacked Brad Scott a couple of weeks ago.   As soon as it happened, the James Hird media mafia went back into gear and started agitating for it to happen. Even Hird himself, alongside a blistering media offensive which included basically every famous former Essendon person, said that it should be Hird because Essendon needs an Essendon man.  My favourite part of the media blitz so far is Jon Pierik’s piece which quotes “two industry sources” – probably James and Tania Hird – who rubbished suggestions that spending a decade out of footy would mean that…

Read More
The Fremantle Fighter Jets 

The Fremantle Fighter Jets 

• GuyWhoLikesSport

There’s something strange happening in Fremantle.   With the new rule changes, footy is having a Woodstock season. It’s all free love and forward handballs baby.   Sydney is the AFL’s Hendrix leading the charge with the 755 metres gained by handball per game over their last five, which is more than 200 more metres than the second leading team, but others are doing it too.   We saw it on Thursday night with Hawthorn, for example. The Hawks are a run and gun team but under Sam Mitchell they’ve historically relied on long wide exits from defence by foot, then short, sharp and aggressive…

Read More
The 2026 AFL Table: Part 1

The 2026 AFL Table: Part 1

• GuyWhoLikesSport

Do you have a seat at the Table?  What table? It’s like the High Table in John Wick. All of the most powerful teams in the AFL are on this table together, as equals and as competitors. Among them, they’ll decide who gets to win the premiership.  But what is it?  The Table is a group of six teams that can win the premiership. That’s it. Only six. I will check in on the Table at about the ¾ mark of the season and then on the eve of the finals and, if all goes well, one of the teams on the Table will win the premiership.   You…

Read More
Pendlebury and the Pies: Thank You and Goodbye 

Pendlebury and the Pies: Thank You and Goodbye 

• GuyWhoLikesSport

I remember going to Dusty Martin’s 300th game a couple of years ago.   Just like old times, hordes of Tiger fans flocked to the MCG to watch the person that lay at the heart of so much of our happiness over the previous five or so years play.   But it was about much more than watching him play again, which we’d all done a hundred times.   It was more about saying thank you. Thank you for all the memories you brought us. Thank you for the brightness you brought after a long fallow period.   He spoke to Jack Riewoldt over the loudspeaker after yet another…

Read More
The Narrative Changers: The AFL Teams We Were Wrong About  

The Narrative Changers: The AFL Teams We Were Wrong About  

• GuyWhoLikesSport

Heading into this year, it felt like we kind of knew who the good teams would be and who the bad teams would be. For the most part, we were right.   Everyone expected Sydney to bounce back and they have, sitting pretty on top of the ladder. By the same token, Richmond was expected to be terrible.  Mission accomplished in that regard.   Even teams like the Saints, who most were lukewarm on despite a big season, have been worthy of that tepidness as they currently sit 9th and at 5-5.  But what are the teams that we were just wrong about? Who changed the narrative on their season?   Let’s look into it.  Melbourne …

Read More
It’s Time to Talk about Alastair 

It’s Time to Talk about Alastair 

• GuyWhoLikesSport

Alastair Clarkson is one of the single best football coaches in my time watching footy.   After a demolition loss to Adelaide that simply shouldn’t be happening in year four of the Clarkson experiment at North Melbourne, after a season of “nearly” games that include close losses to Sydney and GWS, it might be time to reckon with the idea that he might be yesterday’s man.   Two things can be true.   But before heaping dirt on him, we have to remember what he inherited.   The two coaches before him – Rhyce Shaw and David Noble – had a nervous breakdown and were sincerely hated by the players…

Read More
The Fatal Flaw in Every Top 4 Team 

The Fatal Flaw in Every Top 4 Team 

• GuyWhoLikesSport

There’s a clear standout top 4 teams in footy, and they currently occupy the top 4 on the ladder.   But nobody is impervious to weakness. Achilles had the heel, Superman had kryptonite, Tony Soprano had Livia Soprano.   What is the fatal flaw for each of the top 4?   Let’s find out  Sydney: Defending in general  You cannot make a with-ball case against Sydney. They’re ridiculous.   A fortnight ago, I would have said that if you can stop Justin McInerney and Angus Sheldrick’s corridor running lines you can stop Sydney, but both North Melbourne and Melbourne did that over the last two weeks and the Swans still…

Read More
The Complicated Legacy of Michael Voss 

The Complicated Legacy of Michael Voss 

• GuyWhoLikesSport

Michael Voss has the look and feel of a man that is currently being tortured by his dream.   He looks like Fabio Wardley right at the end of his war with Danny Dubois, where he knew that his dream of being the champ was probably dead this time, but he’d still swing a few haymakers just in case a miracle happens.  He knows it’s a matter of when not if he’s given his marching orders, but he still has his boys fighting on grimly while they’re in his charge.   On Friday night, once again, they were competitive and carried a never say die…

Read More